WG 2 – Detection system performance

Since we had previously decided to skip our regular WG2 August meeting, we agreed to use August for finalising our protocols. On August 19th we will meet at our usual WG2 time (5:00 – 6:30PM CEST) for a protocols collection hackathon. This discussion was followed by short reports from the QUAREP-LiMi SC meeting, from the Dutch microscopy association, and about a new QC white paper by evident. During the subsequent agenda point we talked about the next steps towards finalising the NBO-Q camera model and glossary. First final revision meetings by the stakeholder groups were planned for July.

The main agenda point of our 43rd meeting was discussing the next steps towards finalising our protocols for publication. We agreed on the following timeline: until August 19th finalise separate protocols, put them into one collection during the hackathon on August 19th, get the protocols collection tested theoretically and practically and collect example measurements until October 14th. Implement comments and example measurements until November 11th (our WG2 meeting) and present the final protocols collection to the QUAREP-LiMi steering committee on November 12th. To finalise our separate protocols, we formed four small teams who will organise respective discussion meetings. For this version of the protocols collection we decided to keep separate protocols for point and area detectors, respectively. We plan to add protocols based on the French QC paper in the next version of our protocols collection.

After agreeing to take a summer break and skip our August meeting, we discussed the QUAREP-LiMi workshop contributions to ELMI. One workshop was held by WG5 and the other one jointly by WG2 and WG13 members. Both workshops were well received. Several  questions were raised during our joined WG2-WG13 workshop and also during discussions afterwards. These need to be addressed when finalising our protocols. Discussing the steps and the timeline towards publishing our protocols was the next point on our meeting agenda. Participants reported from the meeting with Emma Ganley from protocols.io. Based on that we decided to best publish our protocols in form of a protocols collection. Smaller subgroups will work on the protocols until the July meeting. If need be, we will use the August meeting date for a dedicated protocols hackathon. We aim to present the finished collection to the QUAREP-LiMi steering committee in early fall.

During the organisational and news part, the respective participants reported from the general assembly meeting which took place online on April 16th 2024. Subsequently, the steering committee (SC) was formed and held its inauguration meeting, which our SC members reported from as well. The main topic of our 41st meeting was to discuss and finalise our WG2 workshop on camera topics at ELMI2024. The workshop scheduled was presented, discussed, and approved. A new development was the joining of WG13 in our workshop withe the topic of avoidance of illumination overhead. In addition, we talked about the next steps to finalise and publish our protocols. A meeting with Emma Ganley from protools.io was planned for the next day. We will report from this meeting in the June meeting. As an additional topic, Gert-Jan introduced a possible new standardised light source which could be cheap and easy to built.

After the organisational and news part, we started the meeting with the election of our SC representative, Britta Schroth-Diez, by acclamation. The main topic of our 40th meeting was to discuss our potential contribution to the ELMI2024 community space. As a prerequisite we talked about the needed steps to finalise and ideally publish our protocols until ELMI2024 in June or July. One option is to have a preliminary version and check it during ELMI. We have to ensure to keep the protocols simple with trouble-shooting tips and tricks, also including instructive videos. We will work in smaller groups on the protocols until the May meeting. For our WG2 contribution to the ELMI2024 community space, we are going to do a similar scenario as done last year. Focus will be on ongoing work to automate the workflow. We will also mention our work on the camera glossary. The presenters will meet to prepare a workshop schedule to be shown and discussed during our May meeting.

Part of the meeting was planned to be the announcement of the results for our election of our WG2 co-chairs and representatives to the new governing bodies of QUAREP-LiMi (ERB, OB, SC). Unfortunately, we had some difficulties with the online voting platform. Therefore, we decided to do the elections via acclamation during the meeting. Results of the elections are: Co-chairs (for the next 2 years term): Gert-Jan Bakker, Valeria Berno, David McFadden, and Britta Schroth-Diez. ERB representative: David Grunwald, OB representative: Gerhard Holst. SC representative election will take place in our April meeting. The main topic of our 39th meeting was to discuss our potential contribution to the ELMI2024 community space. We agreed to do a similar workshop as we did last year, with particularly focusing on automation of the workflow and presentation of our protocols. To be able to do so, we need to finalise and ideally publish our protocols until ELMI2024 in June. To be able to do so, we formed two smaller groups to go over the protocols again until the April meeting. In addition to our protocols efforts, we aim to also finalise the joined WG2-7camera glossary project and keep working on our first paper.

In short, the main topic of this meeting was to discuss a potential collaboration with the MetrologyJ_QC group. For that, Orestis and Julien joined us as guests.

We found that both our efforts are complementary and thus can nicely be combined. The MetrologyJ_QC analysis tool focusses on calculating camera read noise, DSNU (dark signal non-uniformity), and hot and cold pixels. Our WG2 analysis tool focusses on calculating the photon-conversion factor. In addition, we as WG2 aim to combine our analysis with an easy to use (automated) acquisition protocol.

Generally, QUAREP-LiMi needs to develop a nice overarching framework for running all our quality control scripts automatically together easily in one tool. Someone needs to take the lead for this endeavour. There is already great groundwork being done, thanks to Kees, for WG1 and also for WG2.

In addition to this main topic there was the report from the last WG9 and WG7 meetings as well as a short review of the next steps to be done toward our paper.

After a short session of QUAREP-LiMi news and updates on our other running projects, we mainly focussed on our planned paper which should accompany the publishing of our protocols. We discussed main aspects, determined topics which need to be addressed and members who our responsible for working on the topics. To be able to have time to do so, we decide to skip the meeting in January 2024.